chat8bit: Mafia

[Fenris]

Originally Posted by The Gentleman Thief

Hey Fenris, you forgot my vote for Secretskull.

Sorry, I kinda did it in a hurry, and didn't notice it. It was kinda in the middle of a paragraph.

Edited it into that post.

[Elbodo]

Ok, a good night's sleep and a look at the thread and my oh my. I will first direct your attention here.


And then to The Gentleman Thief's post here which I shall also quote in this post since I'm gonna be talking about it.

Tell me if I'm wrong, but the cult wins when everybody in the town is converted right? What's the use of helping out the cult by killing non cult members? Shouldn't we concentrate on killing the present cult members instead of the future cult members? Technically, everyone is liable to get drafted, so does that mean that everyone should hang?

Ok, now the first part that TGT quoted from Roy was in reply to a post from Marius Twilight. The second part (where he says "kill them now") is in reply to a previous post by TGT. But when TGT quoted Roy he manipulated them to make it appear that "Kill them now" referred to Twiddy and Sith who were mentioned in the first part. So that rings scummy to my ears. Then, TGT refers to somebody as non-cult members. Maybe he was referring to our known townies or maybe he was referring to Twiddy and Sith -- the text of his post makes it a little hard to tell. In any case throwing that kind of phrase around makes me suspicious.

Add in Mesden's observations about you editing so many posts and things start to really smell scummy. So until I am convinced that this is a bad idea, I'm going to follow my nose and ears and Vote: The Gentleman Thief

Okay, since it looks like I'm going to die anyway, I'm going to Roleclaim: Police Officer.

I was trying to stay as inconspicuous as possible. With the bodyguard already taken out, I wanted to find as much information as possible before revealing myself. The first night I targetted Silly Kitty and Secretskull. I asked if Silly Kitty was Mafia, which she wasn't, and if Secretskull was the Cult Head. Since SK wasn't mafia, I pretty much trusted that what she said was a joke(which is why I unvoted SK after what SS said to make it seem like I didn't unvote her out of the blue), and it was. The second night, I targeted IC alone, who turned out to be the Obvious Townie, or something like that (I only know he's a townie, but I've figured out his personality as well).

I only get their roles, so I can't reveal their name, but hopefully that will be enough to prove it to you today.

Oh, and you know Secretskull? He really is the Cult Head.

Mesden, sorry but the changing posts without editing was a newb mistake. I'm not mafia.

[Truce]

Originally Posted by The Gentleman Thief

I only get their roles, so I can't reveal their name, but hopefully that will be enough to prove it to you today.

Okay, this even I have to question. In all the other Mafia games I've played, the PO also got the name of the character. Why would it be different in this one?

Fenris, does the PO really only get the roles?

[Fenris]

Yeah, but they don't get secret roles at all. The way I see it, there is no need for me to tell 'em the name of the character the person they're investigating is playing.

[Truce]

Meh...I didn't find TGT particularly suspicious in the first place (aside from editing posts, but I never saw what he edited out in the first place)...but this just seems wrong.

Still...if he really is the PO, the mafia will kill him tonight anyway, so I might as well believe his word for now. If they don't, then we'll be sure he's mafia, and can just lynch him tomorrow.

At the very least, I find Secretskull to be a little suspicious himself. He took the first chance he got to vote for Mesden without even bothering to check if his reason was correct (especially in the first day), and while simply accepting that "Garud just felt like being silly" isn't really scummy by itself, it does make me wonder...of course, he does go on to suspect GARUD and me because we voted for each other, but he also forgot to mention I had actual reasons to vote for GARUD posted way before I even made my vote which I know he had to have read, since that was the evidence he used to vote for GARUD in the first place (though, GARUD fake fosing me for something I didn't do was enough to make my final decision).

However, I think I'll wait until IC says something before I change my vote.

[Mesden]

Unvote: The Gentleman Theif

Well, that's about that.

You know why I kind of believe him?

Go ahead and read the first part of this

Seriously, look at it, he’s averting attention from the cult. Just saying, that, plus the fact of “Why Lynch him if he’s screwed either way?” thing.(TGT, that it)

And yeah, I’m waiting for SS and IC to reply first, but SS looks pretty bad off right now. Then again, so does the entire town with the way this seems to be playing out. IE: Losing our BG, Vig and PO in the matter of 2 days.

[MariusTwilight]

Yeah. Loosing those three does seem rather bad. While I'm not inclined enough to vote SS or IC, I'm not going to bother with TGT. From that roleclaim, he'll be most likely dead by tomorrow, so might as well go for someone more suspicious. I've already listed those I find suspicious a couple posts ago.

[Nikose Tyris]

..SecretSkull is the cult head. He has the power to recruit people into cult; why are we not lynching him in an angry mob like formation? Am I missing something important here?

[Mesden]

Originally Posted by Nikose

..SecretSkull is the cult head. He has the power to recruit people into cult; why are we not lynching him in an angry mob like formation? Am I missing something important here?

Because we aren't EXACTLY sure in TGT's roleclaim. IC's response is more important, honestly. But I'd like to see what SS has to say ATLEAST. This may make me seem 'scummy', but hey, voting for him to get an answer need not apply. What with the Roleclaimed PO SAYING you're evil.