Hatland Mafia

[Moogle0119]

While I have been keeping up with the thread in my spare time since my last post, the reasons I haven't posted yet is due to having to spend too much time reading walls of text from various people (not gonna bother posting names) so that I honestly don't HAVE time anymore to respond. The few times I have though, I've very deliberately been not posting and more worried about staying out of the drama that just happened. I rather enjoy playing mafia games and I don't want to see them banned from these forums again because of a few posters.

With that being said...

Unvote: P-Sleazy
Vote: Bard

He's made more than a few posts with absolutely zero content or contribution to the thread. The ones in question....

Originally Posted by Bard The 5th LW

Reading backlog!

This entire post isn't necessary honestly, unless you have something to contribute, clarify, or defend yourself against.

Originally Posted by Bard The 5th LW

ARG BACKLOG

Again, really?

Originally Posted by Bard The 5th LW

Okay I've read most of the backlog, and I'm putting Karesh on my FOS for the moment, because she's being odd. I'd put Shyria there, but Shyria hasn't posted much and you're justified in posting silly shit on your first few posts on D1.

Still not changing my vote for the moment though.

While there is some content here with your FOS towards Karesh and you'd "put Shyria there" in the end you haven't added anything and just continued to pad your post count in this game.

Originally Posted by Bard The 5th LW

ugg i have school soon but i think my thought worked out, see you all around 3

......

Originally Posted by Bard The 5th LW

Well Sif made a lot of my post for me. In shoret, Snake's post are overtly personal, seem really insulting towards who they arew posted at, and don't feeel like they contribute much regardless of length. I didn't even feel like that is MLP mafia! But I do get the distinct feeling of that now.

So yeah, I am actually strongly considering a Snake lynch just to end it.

While reading this it DOES look like you have some suspicions, but you're not really elaborating on anything that someone else already hasn't. It reeks of mafia just parroting someone else's ideas and trying to stay as an active poster for the eventual "let's get the inactives!" phase and also trying to remain inconspicuous.

[Professor Smarmiarty]

Thoughts-
Inactives- Man I waslooking over the player ist and was like Hathater- haven't heard from that person, then I like that'sme.
I'm not going to really crack on any inactives right now, this thread is such a shithole i don't blame them.
I have strong suspicion scum are hiding out under all the shitstorms going on.
Main vote trains

Karesh- Don't have a solid read on karesh. Has a role, could go either way.
Aldurin- He is inexperienced, but his posting behaviour is fluctuating as if he is being primed by other scum. Put in the suspect file.
P-Sleazy- I've played lotsof games with p-sleazy and he's always pretty low active firstfew days so notmuch to say on getting a role of him.
Shyria- Onlymade 1 post dropping a vote on P-sleazy. Probably not reading thread. Dump when we have the chance.
Moogle- I'm buying that he is busy at work. This thread is massive. See how he responds once days get quieter.
Sif- Hard to seperate from the big split with snake. There are vibes here of scum in his slight needling of new vote targets- a classic laying out of threads for town to follow- but his involvement in the snake fight vindicates him a bit.
IC/Fen/Bahamut Flare- good posts so far, but also dropping somethreads. Go back and follow the threads they laid once we get somemore info.

So I'm left with Bard and Snake.
I coudl get behind Bard but I'm going to do this:
Vote:Snake
for the good of the town. All discussion today has been pretty much torpedoed by Snake's antics and he is possibly not coming back so I feel regardless of his alignment this is a solid move.

I also think the scum are hiding- there wa sa big shitstorm today and they would have used that as an excuse to stay low (maybe 1 of them in the shitstorm). Tommorow once we have some more roles look at the outcomes of all the joke votes/voting blocks, there coud be some info here.

[Inbred Chocobo]

I've posted my thoughts on why I am wary of Snake, which doesn't really have anything to do with him causing people to rampage. Since Mr Bookworm won't let me double vote due to the sheer power of awesome, I have to do this to get it to count.

Unvote: Shyria
Vote: Snake

All about the bandwagon people!

[Professor Smarmiarty]

Well I also posted my thoughts on Snake which lead me to believe he was quite scumy-
He delilberately trying to provoke people and stifle discussions and his posts are all very circular and designed to look like he is providing heaps of insight and being helpful when he is actually not doing so at all.
He is more scummy than any other targets we have in my mind but my main number 1 reason for voting is to get the day discussions back on track.

[Bard The 5th LW]

He's made more than a few posts with absolutely zero content or contribution to the thread. The ones in question....

Well Moogle I haven't seen a huge deal of posts from you, if you'll please excuse my manners.

I don't have a huge deal of time on my hands until later in the day. Didn't get back until 5 just yesterday. And whne I do get back, I mostly have to catch up on this huge back and forth between Snake and someone else. Honestly? I pretty much just skimmed a majority of the recent backlog. Those posts I made earlier were right before I was about to leave, but then Sif voted right after me and he didn a good job at saying what I planned to say later.

Fine, I'll go into detail.

Karesh: Her post were all around pretty jumpy and joky, which was a change from what I saw last game, where she struck as a bit more straightforward/logical. I'm looking over the Pony mafia, and my suspicions towards her are easing up, because I actually can't see that she voted for a lynch D1 in there. So yeah, shes being consistent, just some early D1 silliness. Overall her behavior now is meshing up better with her previous behavior.

Shyria: She hasn't given much in the way of posts yet. Her first poist was, once agaij, mostly D1 silliness. Was that to add a veneer to her scumminess and then go undercover? I dunno, might be. If she doesn't post much come D2 than I might be willing to cast a vote for her.

Aldurin: His roleclaims are just weird. First he claims Vanilla and also said that Bookworm apparently wasn't very partial about doling out the role, but now he's a power role? Thats some wishy washy doubletalk. The bizarre nature of these claims make me think that he's just Scum claiming Vanilla, but then he's trying too hard to cover his tracks when people put the heat on him.

Snake: Really, it isn't as much that I think he's scum, but he's really starting to get annoying. I was mostly cool with it last game maybe 'cause I was scum, I dunno. However, it at least seemed more coherent/constructive back then. This time around it seems more like he's delivering some ad hominem and persoanl attacks. I read his post as best as I an, but I don't feel like I get any closer to his point. Just a buvnh of long posts that seem to take some stuff to personally and not deliver a point as quick as it could.

Of these 4, Snake and Aldurin are the only one I can see myself voting at the moment. I'm going to keep it all Aldurin because I feel I have the strongest case against him and he still sort of has a majority. But to all of you who still vote P-sleazy, you should probably just remove it if you don't feel he's a solid case. Someoine's going to have to get lynched, and there's no point in having a joke get that close to a majority.

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Bard.
<---- Male.

[Bard The 5th LW]

Sorry, I keep seeing people say it both ways. Mistake will be rectified for future posts.

[Professor Smarmiarty]

Karesh is trying to fool us into thinking he is a she to lure us into his cult!

[Geminex]

I am... honestly not sure what to make of the whole snake situation. I'm not happy with the thought of a policy lynch, even if his style has been unproductive. Hell, I'm not even sure what's up with him. Apparently he's gone from the game, but he hasn't been replaced? Or will he get replaced? I honestly have no idea, so I'm going to focus on my other suspects, namely earl and Karesh. I've been a bit more cautious this time around, but I'm pretty sure that at least one of those two is up to something. Question is, which one.

Honestly, for all of Earl's suspicious actions (roleclaiming twice, being pretty accusatory with few grounds), I could see him do all those things as town. He's not playing a good game, but he's playing a game that kinda fits within expectations, albeit the low end.

Sure, he might be scum, but he might just be overthinking stuff and trying to right past wrongs. I'm not sure which it is. I'll keep an eye on him...

But honestly, at this point, I'm thinking Karesh might be more suspicious. He's claimed... some kind of role, at least, he's still voting for P-Sleazy because of... joke votes? And he's been all-around wacky. Kinda like nikose last game, though less obviously disruptive.

Don't get me wrong, I don't trust either of them, but Earl at least has the excuse of inexperience. So if I were to vote for one of the two, it'd be Karesh.

As it is, I'll sleep on this and see how the snake thing develops.

[P-Sleazy]

Originally Posted by Karesh

Bard.
<---- Male.

My question has finally been answered!

UNVOTE: Karesh

VOTE: KARESH!

Cause he's not a she. (all the letters are there, just not in the right order).

And also, he did kinda admit to being mafia in his second or third post...WAY WAY Back. Joke claims of mafia have rarely been made by townies in my experience.