Soldiers of Light: Mafia

[CallmePrismatic]

Originally Posted by The SSB Intern

I wanna vote for fenriswolf and TWG, but since that's impossible,
Vote:The Wandering God

The way he's defending himself is somewhat scummy in my opinion.

Scummy you say? You DO realize that the scum attempted to kill him right?

FOS: SSB.

[Major Blood]

Originally Posted by CallmePrismatic

Scummy you say? You DO realize that the scum attempted to kill him right?

FOS: SSB.

I really don't think SSB Intern is suspicious. I really don't think that any mafiate would be as stupid as to say something like that. I'm guessing he just said something stupid(like i did) without realizing it.

[The Wandering God]

Originally Posted by The SSB Intern

I wanna vote for fenriswolf and TWG, but since that's impossible,
Vote:The Wandering God

The way he's defending himself is somewhat scummy in my opinion.

You know what's scummy to me? Having an argument but refusing to refute the other persons points. Every single point FenrisWolf had, I addressed. And continued to address. Feel free to look back over the the posting history to see. I didn't ignore what he had to say, I took it head on.

Want to know what happened? He started this after me and Silly Kitty started talking about her actions. And I was actually mostly convinced of her innocence when guess who showed up out of nowhere.

FenrisWolf. He took ONE comment I made and made a big deal out of it. Then voted for me based on ONE comment. When asked exactly what else he based this on, it was my, single minded attention to someone who had suggested that I could be the CL.

How the hell do you say me or him, anyway?

Oh and,

Originally Posted by Major_Blood

I really don't think SSB Intern is suspicious. I really don't think that any mafiate would be as stupid as to say something like that. I'm guessing he just said something stupid(like i did) without realizing it.

I'm going to use this as an example to talk about intelligence.

Okay, here's the deal. When your whole defense lies around something like, "Oh, I was stupid.", there is a problem. I said it before, and I'll say it again. There is no room for sympathy in this game. ANYONE could be ANYTHING. Voting or not voting for someone based on how new they are, or how stupid they claim to be is wrong. That's why I didn't unvote for DarthMauler when his best defense was, "I was tired". I simply couldn't see how someone would be willing to sit down and write down the equation that started that whole mess, and not doublecheck it. When he said he used a calculator (which, okay, I admit, hadn't thought of as a possibility), then I realized how that mistake could have happened so easily. THAT'S when I unvoted him.

His defense, after I argued everything else away, amounts to nothing more than, "I AM an idiot". (Sorry, Fenris, I hate specific name-calling, but you said that one yourself.)

And I can't unvote for a reason like that. Otherwise, the mafia, imposter, and cult will just manipulate my emotions til I'm 6 feet under.

The Wandering God

[TheSpacePope]

SSB TWG is almost assuradly a townie, almost. And The list of suspects continues to grow.

Here's how I see it

Possible mafiates/killing roles (THIS IS NOT AN FOS, THIS IS AN ANYALTICAL ANALYSIS)

1 FenrisWoLf
2. Silly Kitty
3 Secretskull
4 Skeleton
5. Ahra/Newb

The first four tie together because they seem way to willing to defend one another, and band together to attack another player. A player that I might add had his life almost taken by all three killing roles. So our list has to be 9 people long (really)
So the only other suspicions that I have are

Edited list*
SSB Intern
Catlover
major blood
Bobbey
and b_real

b_real, the ONLY reason that I chose you is that you seem to be able to swing votes easily, that may be due to game experience, or due to the fact that you DO make convincing arguments, but still I am a little wary. But please, ease my mind.


While I can understand where other people are coming from fingering TWG, He has met all accusations to my personal standard and is therefore (at the moment) above my suspicion. THIS IS NOT ME DEFENDING HIM, again, I am listing all of this as a deductive conclusion

And as for newb, I think that He may be a killing role, but he also might be a mason, He just seems like he knows something that I don't, and I have been paying very close attention.
I don't really know though.

Fenris has yet to clear himself in my mind. Given that my ideas do not lend "it was a joke, or I am stupid" as very credible defenses. There is still plenty of time. and my finger is on the unvote button until I get some more information.

Again these are not FoS's they are an opportunity for you all to pick apart my list and find out why my deductions are correct or incorrect. so have at it, tell me what everyone else thinks.

[Bailey]

I seem to know lots because I take the time to keep track of things.

Like with Living Bobbeh suddenly popping up as suspicious on my list and me saying that it was because he made one post, and that was a vote for no-lynch with no real content to it.

I'm crazy good with my spreadsheets, that's all I have to say.

Of course, only one or possibly two people really know for real whether my last guess was right in the other game, and of course we can't talk about that possibility until the game ends, but As more people accuse me of things with flimsy reasons or because I know a lot, I think more and more that the spreadsheet is getting close to the point where it's accurate enough to post.

[P-Sleazy]

Originally Posted by TheSpacePope

So the only other suspicions that I have are

Catlover
major blood
Bobbey
and b_real

b_real, the ONLY reason that I chose you is that you seem to be able to swing votes easily, that may be due to game experience, or due to the fact that you DO make convincing arguments, but still I am a little wary. But please, ease my mind.

Really, I must say I'm Honored that I'm seen as such an influence here. The only reason I can think of that I may be able to swing votes so easily is because when I post, Its usually after reading a good 30-40 posts you guys made which makes it easy for me to see trends in how you guys act from post to post and see who stands out the most.

If you noticed, I usually post only once or twice a day. Also makes my thoughts condensed and from leading off into wild accusations.

And I'm also adding SSB Intern to my list of mafiate for voting for TWG who is clearly town aligned Honestly, even IF he is the CL, its not like its impairing the victory condition for the townies unless he starts killing townies off. He could even be an asset to the town if he gets the Vigilante and then starts recruiting mafiates. He could swing their votes away from the vigilante who could then start killing off converted mafiates as they convert.

Thus the list stands like this

1. Catlover
2. MajorBlood
3. Fenris
4. SSB Intern

And my vote is still on Fenris

[TheSpacePope]

Actually B_real

I never thought of that
I am now adding SSB to my List
and I will edit my above post to reflect that

That is pretty reasonable of you to say, not posting often and getting the ideas from other players, however, I am still shakily looking in your direction.

400th post, woot

[Silly Kitty]

1st point:

How is this a point? What are you seeing that I am not? I wasn't defending Fenris but saying someone else was wrong. And in this I was proven right with a post by Mes.

2nd point:

I just think that Fenris isn't mafia. I was right about IHMN not being mafia. How is this any different?

3rd point:
Hasn't voted for Fenris, like many have.

Like many have? Isn't that bandwagoning? Isn't that bad? Isn't it good to think for yourself? I don't vote for people who I don't believe are mafia.

[Major Blood]

SK, i would just like to point out that your 1st and 2nd points don't actually say anything.

[TheSpacePope]

I believe that kitty was refering to TWG's post
However, I am not ready to discount her totally as a suspect.

I am not ready to discount anyone at this point.

And For the record,
"Hunches"
Are not EVIDENCE.

Ever