NPF Mafia: 8-Bit Edition SP - Page 38

The SSB Intern · 02-03-2006, 12:48 AM

Let's try to figure out what role IHMN is.

Mafia role: Try to make as little susipicion as possible targeted at him or make very good posts so no one could win an argument against him. He has done neither.

Vigilante role: Makes a medium amount of posts and observes everyone's behaviour and try to work outside the box. Nothing here.

Cultist leader: Makes enough posts (whatever s/he deems necessary) to make an educated guess about people's roles and choose the best from the crop. He could have done something like this.

Cultist member: Cares only for the expansion of the cult and its valued members (cultists with powers, leader, etc. Also somewhat suspicuos(sp?) but, not enough to vote for him.

Bodyguard: Makes little to medium posts. Tries to find who looks the least scummy and protects them. Maybe, but probaly not.

Townie: Tries to do whatever it takes to keep #1 alive. Includes bandwagoning and accusations. He could be this too.

Police Officer: I have no idea how this person would act.....

Note: I'm not accusing him of anything, just putting some guidelines you guys might be able to use. My vote is still Vote: No Lynch
Another Note: I'm assuming this is what roles would act like, not really quite sure.

Mesden · 02-03-2006, 03:25 AM

I think the PO would probably leave hints about people until s/he dies. Then people can fo back and look at their posts and see who to get next. Just a guess though.

Trepie · 02-03-2006, 11:30 PM

The Mafia and cultists would try to act exactly like any other townie. If we knew the habits of each role, the game would be easier. Although what you post does make sense we can't really use it to make judgements unless it is supporting evidence...

And the role of Townies is to try to keep all the townies alive, not just yourself.

I don't really want to vote for anybody because I'm against the concept of Lynching until we know 100%. But that is impossible so I'd better start voting before I become completely useless...

My plan is the keep IHMN alive until at least tomorrow and the majority of my suspicions against Neyo have been removed which leaves Fenris.

Vote: FenrisWolf

CallmePrismatic · 02-04-2006, 12:15 AM

ANNOUNCEMENT:

I am now setting a Deadline. Day 3 ends 11:00 P.M. Sunday Night, February 5th. Maybe later, depending on the Super Bowl.

SpoonyBard · 02-04-2006, 07:11 AM

Well, I can't find anything lately. I think that Fenriswolf is basically playing The Wandering God's way for those who remember the last Mafia game. Look what happened to The Wandering God, the only difference is that Fenris is getting lynched much more quickly last game and hasn't even accused anyone with a lengthy damning post as TWG had. Anyway, I can't find much against Fenriswolf, it's just like Fenriswolf has been voted with the mafia snowballing. Thus, I'm going to hold my vote, but I can't help but feel that this will only result in a waste of a vote....

The SSB Intern · 02-04-2006, 12:53 PM

Quote:

And the role of Townies is to try to keep all the townies alive, not just yourself.

Yes, but more often than not townies are usually more concerned about themselves than others, which is kind of a bad of thing. In this game, it's hard to unite the townies because they don't who everyone is. So, they try to keep the one person they know to be town-aligned alive. Themselves.

***Fenris*** · 02-04-2006, 08:28 PM

I'm gonna go with my gut and keep my vote on IHMN. However, if I somehow manage to live through the night, I'm gonna be looking at you, Trepie.

You've done nothing but be against me throughout your entire time in the game. Why? Restate your reasoning for my "guilt". I don't feel you've even done that once...

CallmePrismatic · 02-04-2006, 11:02 PM

Vote Update:

Neyo the King (1)
Garud

FenrisWolf (4)
Inbred Chocobo
IHateMakingNames
Newb
Trepie

IHateMakingNames (3)
Pyros
Neyo the King
FenrisWolf

Mestizio (1)
Baalirock

No Lynch (1)
The SSB Intern

10 TO LYNCH. 24 HOURS TILL DAY ENDS.

Guys, remember to Unvote, it makes a happy GO.

Trepie · 02-04-2006, 11:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FenrisWolf

I'm gonna go with my gut and keep my vote on IHMN. However, if I somehow manage to live through the night, I'm gonna be looking at you, Trepie.

You've done nothing but be against me throughout your entire time in the game. Why? Restate your reasoning for my "guilt". I don't feel you've even done that once...

To put it bluntly, your method of playing seems to be too 'fair'. I know this might sound like a lame reason but as SSB Intern said in his last post, which I agree with now, while the townies are generally for all the town, we want to protect the only people we actually know are townies. And that means, unless you're a mason, you can only really be sure to protect yourself. However, Fenris, you seem to be trying to protect everyone except IHMN. Your posts have always given both sides of the arguement except I don't recall you ever coming up with an alternate defense for him. It seems like you want him to die because you know something. :shifty:

I originally thought that you had a special townie role but after the way IHMN's votes snowballed just as a handful of people found you suspicious seemed like a defensive mechanism from your 'team'. I don't mean any disrespect towards you and I'm not really 'against' you. You're just the only player who I'm finding suspicious at the moment and I thought it would be best for me to vote for someone (I've never played this type of game before and I admit I'm probably being too hasty in an attempt to make myself look like I'm contributing).

Long story short:

1) You seem suspiciously eager to send IHMN to his death without giving both sides like what was your style previously (If you have, please direct me to your post)
2) I'm a n00b who is trying to contribute too much
3) Recently, you seem to be almost too eager to 'pass the buck' to other players such as IHMN and Inbred Chocobo.

Tell you what. Having just realised I've acted too hastily in an pathetic attempt to contribute and impress. I'll remove my vote for you and we'll see what IHMN's real role is. If it is evil, or the vig (and you're worried about his random SK style killings) then I will completely remove any suspicion of you from my mind.

Unvote:FenrisWolf

Vote:No Lynch

Deathosaurus Wrecks · 02-05-2006, 02:21 AM

As promised, here is my updated post. again, my apologies for my temporary absence. those of you who have played MMO's would understand.

I'm willing to agree with Mestizio on the point that IHMN is probably more valuable to us alive than dead, so for the time being i'll ease off him. However I'm still uncertain as to the votes for Neyo. I don't see his one vote for an innocent (one that was endorsed by the majority, i remind you) as being lynch worthy suspicion. Fenris's accusation that Mestizio being the cult leader, or something sinister, seems baseless in my mind, which leads me back to my earlier theories.

i hate backtracking, and i hate contradicting myself, but in my mind theres really only one choice this round. Vote: FenrisWolf

02-03-2006, 12:48 AM	#371
The SSB Intern We'll have to do this the hard way. Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Behind it all. Posts: 1,009	Let's try to figure out what role IHMN is. Mafia role: Try to make as little susipicion as possible targeted at him or make very good posts so no one could win an argument against him. He has done neither. Vigilante role: Makes a medium amount of posts and observes everyone's behaviour and try to work outside the box. Nothing here. Cultist leader: Makes enough posts (whatever s/he deems necessary) to make an educated guess about people's roles and choose the best from the crop. He could have done something like this. Cultist member: Cares only for the expansion of the cult and its valued members (cultists with powers, leader, etc. Also somewhat suspicuos(sp?) but, not enough to vote for him. Bodyguard: Makes little to medium posts. Tries to find who looks the least scummy and protects them. Maybe, but probaly not. Townie: Tries to do whatever it takes to keep #1 alive. Includes bandwagoning and accusations. He could be this too. Police Officer: I have no idea how this person would act..... Note: I'm not accusing him of anything, just putting some guidelines you guys might be able to use. My vote is still Vote: No Lynch Another Note: I'm assuming this is what roles would act like, not really quite sure. __________________ You know who never sleeps? My gun. Last edited by The SSB Intern; 02-03-2006 at 12:52 AM.

02-03-2006, 03:25 AM	#372
Mesden There is no Toph, only Melon Lord! Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Inside of a box inside of a smaller box Posts: 4,310	I think the PO would probably leave hints about people until s/he dies. Then people can fo back and look at their posts and see who to get next. Just a guess though. __________________ I can tell you're lying.

02-03-2006, 11:30 PM	#373
Trepie Yay for the Fan Art thread! Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: In a field of purple flowers Posts: 123	The Mafia and cultists would try to act exactly like any other townie. If we knew the habits of each role, the game would be easier. Although what you post does make sense we can't really use it to make judgements unless it is supporting evidence... And the role of Townies is to try to keep all the townies alive, not just yourself. I don't really want to vote for anybody because I'm against the concept of Lynching until we know 100%. But that is impossible so I'd better start voting before I become completely useless... My plan is the keep IHMN alive until at least tomorrow and the majority of my suspicions against Neyo have been removed which leaves Fenris. Vote: FenrisWolf __________________ The greatest line in 8-bit history: :thief: No I wasn't, besides, what kind of ninja wears bright red? I came back because of Celebren's artwork.

02-04-2006, 08:28 PM	#377
*Fenris* Administrator Join Date: May 2005 Location: East Coast Posts: 6,806	I'm gonna go with my gut and keep my vote on IHMN. However, if I somehow manage to live through the night, I'm gonna be looking at you, Trepie. You've done nothing but be against me throughout your entire time in the game. Why? Restate your reasoning for my "guilt". I don't feel you've even done that once... __________________ "FENRIS IS AN ASSHOLE" - shiney

02-05-2006, 02:21 AM	#380
Deathosaurus Wrecks Underachiever Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Chicago Posts: 1,996	As promised, here is my updated post. again, my apologies for my temporary absence. those of you who have played MMO's would understand. I'm willing to agree with Mestizio on the point that IHMN is probably more valuable to us alive than dead, so for the time being i'll ease off him. However I'm still uncertain as to the votes for Neyo. I don't see his one vote for an innocent (one that was endorsed by the majority, i remind you) as being lynch worthy suspicion. Fenris's accusation that Mestizio being the cult leader, or something sinister, seems baseless in my mind, which leads me back to my earlier theories. i hate backtracking, and i hate contradicting myself, but in my mind theres really only one choice this round. Vote: FenrisWolf __________________ "There was another, who came before you he was a hero and your brother and my son he fought the darkenss, the darkness won" -The Protomen "Unrest in the House of Light" Last edited by Deathosaurus Wrecks; 02-05-2006 at 02:36 PM.

02-04-2006, 07:11 AM	#375
SpoonyBard [Insert Custom Title] Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 103	Well, I can't find anything lately. I think that Fenriswolf is basically playing The Wandering God's way for those who remember the last Mafia game. Look what happened to The Wandering God, the only difference is that Fenris is getting lynched much more quickly last game and hasn't even accused anyone with a lengthy damning post as TWG had. Anyway, I can't find much against Fenriswolf, it's just like Fenriswolf has been voted with the mafia snowballing. Thus, I'm going to hold my vote, but I can't help but feel that this will only result in a waste of a vote....