chat8bit: Mafia - Page 39

Roy_D_Mylote · 07-30-2006, 02:31 PM

If you investigated TGT before he got secretskull lynched, why didn't you speak up and save the townie?

Mesden · 07-30-2006, 02:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roy_D_Mylote

If you investigated TGT before he got secretskull lynched, why didn't you speak up and save the townie?

He apparently didn't choose to reveal himself to kill a mafia and save a townie, rather than "Catch the Cult Leader" or so he puts it thusly.

MariusTwilight · 07-30-2006, 02:40 PM

I was being newbish and did an idiot mistake. I didn't know SS was a townie at all.

Edit: I had investigated someone else that day.

Roy_D_Mylote · 07-30-2006, 02:46 PM

What I was asking is, why didn't you say that TGT was mafia when he tried to get secretskull lynched? Did you not want to risk death or what? I'm confused by your answer.

Demonlink2 · 07-30-2006, 02:56 PM

Quote:

I was being newbish and did an idiot mistake. I didn't know SS was a townie at all.

Okay, but what? What did you think an obvious liar was doing? Trying to get a mafia member? I'm confused too.

Sithdarth · 07-30-2006, 02:57 PM

Wait one second there. The PO role wasn't reassigned, according to Fenris, until after SS was lynched. As shown here. So Raiden must have, or Fenris did it at random(of course that also assumes Marius is telling the truth), and even then Marius could have done nothing to help SS or to get TGT lynched sooner. Frankly once SS came up townie TGT was dead regardless of what the PO knew.

Well Fenris could have reassigned the role earlier but why not tell us? Of course I really could have missinturpeted what Fenris said so that Marius got his roll the day before Raiden was kicked. But then he would still know TGT was lieing. However, he could have been worried about a reveal and getting hit at night but then why come out with it all later?

Truce · 07-30-2006, 03:00 PM

I don't know why, but this feels different from TGT's attempt. He did get suspicious of Mesden right out of the blue, and I don't particularly like this assumption.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mesden

You know, think about my power. Now think about how the cultists apparently draft people. Now put two and two together and maybe the cult failed the night before the Elbodo draft and now they want me dead as to get that out of the way (Someone they wasted a recruitment on and can never be on their side) and what's one draftee to rid them of an overall threat?

Now, I'm a little skeptic about Mesden having an unkillable personality as well as the cult leader role, but I'm suspicious of why she wants us to assume that the Paranoid personality cannot be inducted by the cult.

Quote:

Originally Posted by FenrisWolf

Mesden: Cannot be killed overnight. Period.

As you can see, Fenriswolf says she cannot be killed overnight; no mention of never being inducted by the cult at all. More importantly, if the cult had attempted a recruitment on her and it failed, I'd expect something to show up on the night posts, with Mesden either running away again or chasing them off.

Roy_D_Mylote · 07-30-2006, 03:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sithdarth

Wait one second there. The PO role wasn't reassigned, according to Fenris, until after SS was lynched. As shown here. So Raiden must have, or Fenris did it at random(of course that also assumes Marius is telling the truth), and even then Marius could have done nothing to help SS or to get TGT lynched sooner. Frankly once SS came up townie TGT was dead regardless of what the PO knew.

Well Fenris could have reassigned the role earlier but why not tell us? Of course I really could have missinturpeted what Fenris said so that Marius got his roll the day before Raiden was kicked. But then he would still know TGT was lieing. However, he could have been worried about a reveal and getting hit at night but then why come out with it all later?

I thought that the new PO would have access to all of the prievous one's information.

EDIT: Anyway, MT said he investigated TGT "before the whole lynching thing" so he would've known that TGT was mafia and coulda spoke up.

Mesden · 07-30-2006, 03:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ecurt

Unvote: MariusTwilight
Vote: Mesden

I don't know why, but this feels different from TGT's attempt. He did get suspicious of Mesden right out of the blue, and I don't particularly like this assumption.

Now, I'm a little skeptic about Mesden having an unkillable personality as well as the cult leader role, but I'm suspicious of why she wants us to assume that the Paranoid personality cannot be inducted by the cult.

As you can see, Fenriswolf says she cannot be killed overnight; no mention of never being inducted by the cult at all. More importantly, if the cult had attempted a recruitment on her and it failed, I'd expect something to show up on the night posts, with Mesden either running away again or chasing them off.

Hold it there, buddy. I'm just trying to point out the reasons why it doesn't sound right when you apply my role to the Cult.

Think about it. The cult leader goes to someone and marks them as cult at night, right? Well, my CHARACTER is paranoid about people coming to her. Seeing as the Mafia came and then I locked my doors, only to hear them talk about killing me before I left through my secret tunnel.

So, if the cult came to my character at night, wouldn't the paranoia thing kick in logically? It wasn't much more than simple speculation on my part, so I don't think it's some scum indicator, but, do as you wish.

Roy_D_Mylote · 07-30-2006, 03:05 PM

Hey. Why did Ecurt edit out the vote thing?

07-30-2006, 02:31 PM	#381
Roy_D_Mylote Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: The sky. Posts: 1,030	If you investigated TGT before he got secretskull lynched, why didn't you speak up and save the townie? __________________ I hate roleclaims.

07-30-2006, 02:46 PM	#384
Roy_D_Mylote Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: The sky. Posts: 1,030	What I was asking is, why didn't you say that TGT was mafia when he tried to get secretskull lynched? Did you not want to risk death or what? I'm confused by your answer. __________________ I hate roleclaims.

07-30-2006, 02:57 PM	#386
Sithdarth Friendly Neighborhood Quantum Hobo Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Outside the M-brane look'n in Posts: 5,403	. Wait one second there. The PO role wasn't reassigned, according to Fenris, until after SS was lynched. As shown here. So Raiden must have, or Fenris did it at random(of course that also assumes Marius is telling the truth), and even then Marius could have done nothing to help SS or to get TGT lynched sooner. Frankly once SS came up townie TGT was dead regardless of what the PO knew. Well Fenris could have reassigned the role earlier but why not tell us? Of course I really could have missinturpeted what Fenris said so that Marius got his roll the day before Raiden was kicked. But then he would still know TGT was lieing. However, he could have been worried about a reveal and getting hit at night but then why come out with it all later?

07-30-2006, 03:05 PM	#390
Roy_D_Mylote Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: The sky. Posts: 1,030	Hey. Why did Ecurt edit out the vote thing? __________________ I hate roleclaims.

07-30-2006, 02:40 PM	#383
MariusTwilight Waitwut? Join Date: May 2006 Location: There's lots of dark things! Posts: 26	I was being newbish and did an idiot mistake. I didn't know SS was a townie at all. Edit: I had investigated someone else that day.