06-15-2006, 01:29 PM | #401 | |
Ehhhhhh?
|
Hm, I did forget the vig didn't have to make a hit. In that case I will Unvote: Big Mac. I just wanted to make sure the town didn't lose it in one night.
Newb, can we get a vote count? Edit: Also, TWG, who are you to tell the vig what to do? You are a known townie but the vig may have someone else s/he wants to hit.
__________________
SillyKitty: Adorable psychopath of the Official NPF Anti-Zombie Survival Army Quote:
Last edited by Silly Kitty; 06-15-2006 at 01:32 PM. |
|
06-15-2006, 01:33 PM | #402 | |
There is no Toph, only Melon Lord!
|
Quote:
I, like you, believe CmP is mafia. His Role seems more of a shoddy excuse(Like I said) and the entire rest of this thread goes to show it. I believe that Twiddy is mafia. He's BEING a mafiate. Nothing he's done is an excuse. I gave my reasons why in my post. But the vig may not think the same way. For all we know, the vig could be taking the IHMN route with random kills. But what of the chance that we're wrong? Surely the Vig will think this(If s/he's an actual active player) through and may disagree. My vote stays with Twiddy, as CmP has at least the SLIGHTEST of a real excuse where as Twid just seems unprepared and caught off guard.
__________________
I can tell you're lying. |
|
06-15-2006, 01:53 PM | #403 | ||
THE SUPREME COURT DID WHAT?
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Arkansas (for now)
Posts: 1,477
|
Quote:
Ah yes, the vig should make their own decisions. After all, we'd hate for them to be following any sort of consensus. (Who do you think should be hit SK?) I mean, it's not like another townie agrees with me or anything... Hold on, what's that down there? Quote:
Let's take a look at my track record: Catlover: thought he was guilty Mesden: after back and forth, I thought you were innocent (before you were revealed) B_real: Thought he was a townie Ogianres: Mistake here, I thought he could be mafia That's 3 out of 4 correct. As compared to say... CmP, who is 0 for 4 for those very same people. That's why I feel that I can make suggestions. And as to the current two major suspects, you (another townie) agree with me. Why shouldn't the vig be willing to believe not one, but two people who are innocent? And yes, we could be wrong. Of course, anyone could be wrong. But if we are too paralyzed to do anything, the mafia has already won. But think about it this way... Maybe we're right. If CmP and Twiddy are both mafiates, that leaves just 2 to find, with a little bit more breathing room to do so. So, we can play it safe, or not. But I guess it really is up to the vig. I wish there was a vote count so I could see where things stack up. The Wandering God |
||
06-15-2006, 01:54 PM | #404 | |
RP Lord
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Mafia Don
Posts: 1,161
|
Yeah, some clarification by Newb on how inactive-dropkicking works would be appreciated at this juncture.
However, I think there's a pretty good chance that the inactives are mafia, although it involves me speculating on how Newb is thinking. What is one of the reasons you wouldn't kick out an inactive player? Because they have a role. BUT, plenty of people with roles have dropped out and they have merely been reassigned. Of course, that might be due to the fact that the people involved requested a drop out, while we're stuck assuming the inactives are not communicating both in-game nor with Newb. Anyways, assuming Newb hasn't kicked them out due to the fact that they have roles, we have to look at what roles there are. We can assume that the Vig is someone who's at least semi-active because they could only have gotten the role by paying attention the thread and contacting Newb. The Doc is dead, and likewise the SK. That leaves the PO and Reporter, and mafia roles. I'm going to assume the Reporter is someone who pays attention to the thread because he/she has investigated Mes and TWG, two-thirds of the most active player trinity. That leaves the PO and mafia roles. Since Newb hasn't said anything further about people not PMing roles, we have to assume that the PO has been active, at least at Night, and to make any decisions they would have had to read the thread for a vague sense of who to investigate, and thus would see all of the doubt over inactive players and chime in. A vast majority of the mafia, however, have no compulsion to post in the game thread or PM Newb, and benefit when no undue attention is paid to them. Of course, all of this depends entirely on the assumption that the only reason inactive players haven't been kicked off is because they have a role. That's why, until Newb ever lets us in on his plan, I'm going to keep my vote on Mac. On the topic of my 'fake' role claim...look around. This is the first game using non-traditional roles (No offense Mes, but your Chi was essentially a versatile SK). Somebody is the Reporter, Ogian was a Role Watcher, TWG has some sort of Doc-calling capability...just because you've never heard of the role before doesn't mean I had to have made it up. On the other hand, if you think I made it up because it couldn't be verified, that's false. Let the PO or Reporter waste a Night investigating me. Although, to indulge in some Mesden-esque "If I were a mafiate" pondering, a mafiate who wants to fake-claim would probably say they were the PO. At that point the real PO would be forced to step up, and even if the mafiate died he would have succeeded in getting the PO to show himself. I also want to touch on something SK inadvertently spoke of: The Vig. At this point, each miss that hits a townie is practically handing the game to the mafia. Unless a PO comes forth and says with undeniable proof that so-and-so is a mafiate, sending a silver bullet off of a hunch is detrimental to the town.
__________________
Want to run a Mafia game? Better sign-up then. Currently Running Games: Inexperienced Mafia - Run by Me - Running NPF Mafia - Run by GARUD - Sign Up Forum Fact: You aren't cool if you haven't corrupted a wish. Quote:
|
|
06-15-2006, 02:08 PM | #405 | ||
There is no Toph, only Melon Lord!
|
Quote:
Quote:
Twiddy, yes, you did bring the light on him. But didn't I ARGUE against some of your points and then MADE my ENTIRE own reason for voting? One that had little to do with what you said? Yeah, no one has convinced me of anything. I've convinced myself. I may "Agree" with you, but not because of anything you've said. Don't make it look like we're tag team buddies here. You went to CmP after I proved myself good in your eyes and him bad. I went for Twiddy with my OWN reasons. Got that? As far as the vig, you said yourself, known townies AREN'T infalliable. You know what a VIGILANTE is? It's someone who works by themselves to bring justice by their own opinion. This is why in game 2 I didn't vote for IHMN, because he was being a vig in his own way. It IS the Vig's choice. YOU are not always right, no matter the track record. The vig may not want to state who he thinks is guilty because, hey, when he KILLS them at night, the mafia will look at HIM. Think about that, please. Also, don't assume anything about me. My "Agreement" is merely mutual concern for different reasons. I'll NEVER be the person who says, "Vote: Someone because of those things other people stated."
__________________
I can tell you're lying. |
||
06-15-2006, 02:14 PM | #406 |
Argus Agony
|
I cast my vote for POS Industries. That fucker's up to something, I just know it.
__________________
Either you're dead or my watch has stopped. |
06-15-2006, 02:15 PM | #407 | |
THE SUPREME COURT DID WHAT?
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Arkansas (for now)
Posts: 1,477
|
Quote:
But actually, your points only emphasize what I was trying to say. 2 independant lines of thought arrived at the same conclusion. Doesn't that mean something to you? And the Vig is a TOWNIE first and foremost. They are NOT the serial killer. If they aren't going after who the town (Who basically consists of you and me being confirmed innocent) thinks is guilty, they are dangerous. Just because you didn't vote for IHMN, didn't make him any less so. And since we only have one death to judge our new Vig by (a townie) I don't entirely trust their line of thinking. Can you blame me? And if I'm so incredibly stupid, please ignore my posts for the insane ramblings you take them to be from now on, as they apparently mean nothing to you. The Wandering God |
|
06-15-2006, 02:31 PM | #408 | ||||||||
There is no Toph, only Melon Lord!
|
Now time to be the disecting surgeon.
Quote:
Quote:
Oh, and on Twiddy, I haven't said I agreed or supported any of your points. Argued some I did. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
But right now, you're running off of a "Holier than thou" attitude. It's upsetting some people. I, for one, don't like your needless over agression, which you're only allowed to live with because of your revealation. Tone it down a bit, don't assume things about me and stop acting infalliable. Whether you think you are or not, it's true. Other people in and outside the game have informed me about this(Not cheating, just saying how you were acting.).
__________________
I can tell you're lying. |
||||||||
06-15-2006, 03:24 PM | #409 | ||||||||||||
THE SUPREME COURT DID WHAT?
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Arkansas (for now)
Posts: 1,477
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
And again, I never thought he was a mafiate. Quote:
Quote:
And I'm agressive because A) I feel it's what the situation calls for. Mafiates can always say, "Why are you being so aggresive?" and point the finger at their accuser. however B) I'm a townie now. It only allows me to fully conduct the hunt for the mafiates in our presence. It doesn't confer any special powers but the ability for others to know it's the voice of a townie speaking. Quote:
And I just love your super-secret clubs and little whisper groups. You KNOW how I feel about those. I guess I just have my own little sense of judgement to go by. Must be damn nice to have the input of others. And as much as you tell me not to tell the vig how to act, I'm surpised at the hypocrisy that you are trying to say, "Don't act that way." The Wandering God Last edited by The Wandering God; 06-15-2006 at 03:28 PM. |
||||||||||||
06-15-2006, 04:00 PM | #410 | |||||||||||||||||
There is no Toph, only Melon Lord!
|
Quote:
Quote:
You're TELLING the vig what to do. That's not asking the rest of the town. You're SAYING that you're going to get Twiddy killed next. That's not asking the town, though it holds the capacity to do so. Quote:
Quote:
There's no other logic I can wholeheartedly believe besides my own. It's just how I am because I can't follow another's lead. I need to have my own belief of someone's scum, not your belief. Quote:
But you did say you would follow my lead. That was enough for me to not accept anything you said and go off on my own. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
[qupte]No, but it does confirm that maybe they aren't the best judge of who to kill. Are you trying to say B_Real isn't any less dead? Because he is. And the list's of reasons for CmP and Twiddy would probably outweigh those. [/quote] Maybe not. But who says you and I are? Why should they follow us? There's no guarantee that CmP and Twiddy are mafia. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
You've made people feel bad and upset over a game. This is where everyone needs to calm down and take it as a game. Quote:
I'm not telling you how to act. I'm asking you, person to person, to PLEASE just tone it down a wee bit as to not upset others. It's not an order, it's a request as a person. Again, don't assume things about me and insult me. This is a game and saying these things are unnecessary. Edit: Quoting problem
__________________
I can tell you're lying. Last edited by Mesden; 06-15-2006 at 04:03 PM. |
|||||||||||||||||
|
|