Stargate SG1 Mafia - Page 47

Moogle0119 · 10-21-2006, 09:27 AM

I'm sorry I probably should have clarified what I meant when I said ...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moogle0119

I'm honestly not sure but like I said he seems the scummiest of the 4 on the list. For me, I'm going to be torn between Cephrir and Bungalobill6 myself since neither one of them stand out more than the other in my opinion. Let's just hope we get lucky or someone slips up.

....was that out of the list of 4 that we had narrowed it down to, I thought Mr.Bookworm was the scummiest of those 4. After that however I am really torn between Cephrir and Bungalobill6. Sorry for the confusion there.

I have to admit I am VERY relieved you believe my innocence Mesden since I see you as the only person we all know is not scum. Skyshot and secretskull can't be the replicator/serial killer but the may be Anubis possessed (still though, less likely to be scum than the 4 on the list). I was thinking about the serial killer's motives and for everyone who keeps saying I seem "suspicious" I now have pretty good proof I can't be the serial killer (let's listen with open minds for just a moment).

The replicator/serial killer is on his own team correct? Now in MOST mafia games how does the serial killer win? Anyone? That's right, he wins by being the last person alive. So his job is to make sure that neither the town NOR the mafia wins prior to that. Since the mafia can win by having more than half the town be mafia, I doubt they'd let the mafia get that out of hand and they would actively try to keep the game going until the end when there's only 2-3 people left. Same goes for the town. The serial killer doesn't want the town to prematurely kill off the mafia members because if all 5 die, then it's game over and town wins (regardless of the cult or serial killers if I'm reading the rules correctly).

So with these facts in mind, I have to ask who has been the most iffy on votes? If you read through all my posts there have been only two times I was unsure of a vote to be placed. The first was on Inbred Chocobo on the first night since we had nothing to go on (lucky me though later on he WAS Goa'uld anyway). After that the only other vote I messed up on was secretskull (who hadn't even posted until we started accusing him of being scum). Every single other vote has been placed on a mafiate or cult leader. To keep pointing a finger at me seems really innane and can't be backed up with any facts other than "he seems suspicious" or "too pro-town".

The point of all this is if the serial killer's motivation was to keep both the town AND mafia alive until the end, let's look through the posts and see who has exhibited that sort of behavior. Granted it will be hard but I'm going to give the thread another thorough read and compare Mr.Bookworm, Cephrir, and Bungalobill6 and look for anything new. Anyway Mesden I think I'll be standing by my vote on Mr.Bookworm since he hasn't even tried to defend himself and his apathy alone makes it not even worth keeping him if he even is a townie. Not much else to say though other than that on Mr.Bookworm.

Mr.Bookworm · 10-21-2006, 08:06 PM

The reason I haven't "tried to defend myself" is because I don't have anything to defend myself with. None of us except Mesden, Skyshot, and secretskull (to the best of my knowledge) have any solid ground to defend themselves on. And you're acting like you're above and beyond being capable of being lynched. Behavior like that, to me, is suspicious. And saying that I'm not even worth keeping even if I am a townie is just plain stupid. You haven't shown any real evidence against me that's suspicious, except the whole "he's not posting enough!" thing, which is due to the thing called my "real life".

I don't mean to start anything, especially a flamewar, but you are acting suspicious, in my opinion.

Vote: Moogle0119

You've just been acting way too odd.

Moogle0119 · 10-21-2006, 09:48 PM

That's ok Mr.Bookworm no personal offense is taken here after all it is just a game and it's no reason to lose sleep over. Your vote however just seems like a "well if he's voting for me then I'm voting for him!" kind of whim without much behind it. I've given reasons as to why you're the most suspicious out of the list of 3 between you, Cephrir, and Bungalobill6 and I've backed it up with facts. I even mentioned in a previous post that I wasn't sure whether your sporadic posts was due to real life calls or not since I do understand that there is that so called "real life" outside of this game as you so put it.

Not once have I pretended to act like I can't be lynched because it's a very real possibility and honestly I'm very surprised I haven't been killed off by the Goa'uld for pointing out so many of their members so quickly. I have even put myself on the list of suspects that could possibly be the replicator/serial killer as well as Anubis possessed so I don't see where you get the idea that I have this invincible complex.

Hell I even described what the replicator/serial killer would be thinking in the beginning of the game (prior to all the twists and turns this mafia game has presented) and in no way, shape, or form does it benefit a serial killer to point out EVERY SINGLE MAFIATE with a vote, since doing so would end the game prematurely and thus the serial killer would lose. I have backed up a good portion of my theories and votes with facts, and it only benefits the town to view these facts and base opinions on them.

The whole reason I said you were not worth keeping around even if you were a townie is because of your lackluster attitude since you have been pinpointed as the most likely suspect during the current day. Let's entertain the idea that we ended up voting for someone else to lynch (including myself if you want) and the game continued on because it was another townie that we lynched. What benefit would you provide the town other than your "If you vote me, you'll just lose" attitude? You don't seem to want to particpate in the gathering of facts and figuring out who is scum through those facts. I tried to point out to you that having such an attitude doesn't benefit the town at all and if you are indeed innocent you should try your very best to show evidence why you are less suspicious than someone else. Remember, this is a mafia game, and while it may be the first one I have participated in I know that without facts all it comes down to is a game of "my word versus your word". Facts in this game are something everyone can agree with because it's solid. I'd rather trust facts more than gut instinct (however if I do have a gut instinct about someone I usually end up asking myself why and proceed to look for facts to back it up. This actually is what ended up happening when I voted for Newb in the beginning.) Unfortunately in this game you are usually guilty until proven innocent and the best way to prove innocence is with facts. So without facts still and without ANY case to present your innocence you honestly just keep looking scummier and scummier to me with each post. I'm sorry but that is the way you are portraying yourself to me.

Now that I've replied to each of your accusations I have to ask you one question, in what way have I "been acting way too odd"? I've only once made one bad vote the entire game and it was against secretskull since he hadn't posted at all in the entire thread up to that point and in my defense I believe many others were voting for him as well (including Mesden). Again your posts abandon anything factual which others may see as well and the more you keep posting about how others are scummy it is just making you seem like you really have nothing to say, and thus prove our point.

Sithdarth · 10-24-2006, 10:48 PM

Deadline Wednesday at around 9:00PM EST.

Moogle0119 · 10-26-2006, 09:28 AM

Tick Tock
The deadline's up

Sithdarth · 10-27-2006, 10:59 AM

Once again the SGC gathers to put to death one they deem a traitor. Zats at the ready they surrond Mr. Bookworm and fire in rapid succession. As their victims body vanishes into nothing they notice something strange. Replicators are immune to Zats and so Mr. Bookworm Vanillia Tauri was gone.

As the few remaining members awaken they find Moogle0119 quite torn up and looking rather haggard. Slowly he begins to mouth words so softly no one can quite here them. Suddenly he falls into a heap a dark mist drifting out of him the detached limb of a replicator still sticking out of his back. As the SGC looks on in hour the dark mist raises up as if to menace them before slowly dissapating. Thus ended Moogle0119 Vanilla Townie(Newly possesed).

Moogle0119 · 10-27-2006, 11:08 AM

Wow I didn't even know that had happened to me, in any case good luck town I hope you get that replicator!

Mr.Bookworm · 10-27-2006, 03:38 PM

Good luck.

And start postin' people!

Cephrir · 10-27-2006, 09:38 PM

I guess it's up to Mesden to decide. I guess I'll defend if Mesden votes me before Bungalobill does, but otherwise I just don't see the point.
Vote Bungalobill6.

Bungalobill6 · 10-28-2006, 01:12 PM

Vote:Cephrir
The reasons are obvious. It is either him or me.

10-27-2006, 09:38 PM	#469
Cephrir With no _s! Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: In the wild. Posts: 24	I guess it's up to Mesden to decide. I guess I'll defend if Mesden votes me before Bungalobill does, but otherwise I just don't see the point. Vote Bungalobill6. __________________ :rmage: See, anytime you do anything, the_e is a one in twenty chance that you will c_itically fail.

10-28-2006, 01:12 PM	#470
Bungalobill6 pikpik carrots... yum Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: yonder Posts: 3	Vote:Cephrir The reasons are obvious. It is either him or me. __________________ Yay mookie! My English is better than some people's, I don't use comma splicing.

10-21-2006, 08:06 PM	#462
Mr.Bookworm YYYEEEEEAAAAAAHHH Join Date: Jul 2006 Posts: 2,034	The reason I haven't "tried to defend myself" is because I don't have anything to defend myself with. None of us except Mesden, Skyshot, and secretskull (to the best of my knowledge) have any solid ground to defend themselves on. And you're acting like you're above and beyond being capable of being lynched. Behavior like that, to me, is suspicious. And saying that I'm not even worth keeping even if I am a townie is just plain stupid. You haven't shown any real evidence against me that's suspicious, except the whole "he's not posting enough!" thing, which is due to the thing called my "real life". I don't mean to start anything, especially a flamewar, but you are acting suspicious, in my opinion. Vote: Moogle0119 You've just been acting way too odd.

10-21-2006, 09:48 PM	#463
Moogle0119 The REAL Lord of the Dance Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Narshe Caves Posts: 397	That's ok Mr.Bookworm no personal offense is taken here after all it is just a game and it's no reason to lose sleep over. Your vote however just seems like a "well if he's voting for me then I'm voting for him!" kind of whim without much behind it. I've given reasons as to why you're the most suspicious out of the list of 3 between you, Cephrir, and Bungalobill6 and I've backed it up with facts. I even mentioned in a previous post that I wasn't sure whether your sporadic posts was due to real life calls or not since I do understand that there is that so called "real life" outside of this game as you so put it. Not once have I pretended to act like I can't be lynched because it's a very real possibility and honestly I'm very surprised I haven't been killed off by the Goa'uld for pointing out so many of their members so quickly. I have even put myself on the list of suspects that could possibly be the replicator/serial killer as well as Anubis possessed so I don't see where you get the idea that I have this invincible complex. Hell I even described what the replicator/serial killer would be thinking in the beginning of the game (prior to all the twists and turns this mafia game has presented) and in no way, shape, or form does it benefit a serial killer to point out EVERY SINGLE MAFIATE with a vote, since doing so would end the game prematurely and thus the serial killer would lose. I have backed up a good portion of my theories and votes with facts, and it only benefits the town to view these facts and base opinions on them. The whole reason I said you were not worth keeping around even if you were a townie is because of your lackluster attitude since you have been pinpointed as the most likely suspect during the current day. Let's entertain the idea that we ended up voting for someone else to lynch (including myself if you want) and the game continued on because it was another townie that we lynched. What benefit would you provide the town other than your "If you vote me, you'll just lose" attitude? You don't seem to want to particpate in the gathering of facts and figuring out who is scum through those facts. I tried to point out to you that having such an attitude doesn't benefit the town at all and if you are indeed innocent you should try your very best to show evidence why you are less suspicious than someone else. Remember, this is a mafia game, and while it may be the first one I have participated in I know that without facts all it comes down to is a game of "my word versus your word". Facts in this game are something everyone can agree with because it's solid. I'd rather trust facts more than gut instinct (however if I do have a gut instinct about someone I usually end up asking myself why and proceed to look for facts to back it up. This actually is what ended up happening when I voted for Newb in the beginning.) Unfortunately in this game you are usually guilty until proven innocent and the best way to prove innocence is with facts. So without facts still and without ANY case to present your innocence you honestly just keep looking scummier and scummier to me with each post. I'm sorry but that is the way you are portraying yourself to me. Now that I've replied to each of your accusations I have to ask you one question, in what way have I "been acting way too odd"? I've only once made one bad vote the entire game and it was against secretskull since he hadn't posted at all in the entire thread up to that point and in my defense I believe many others were voting for him as well (including Mesden). Again your posts abandon anything factual which others may see as well and the more you keep posting about how others are scummy it is just making you seem like you really have nothing to say, and thus prove our point.

10-24-2006, 10:48 PM	#464
Sithdarth Friendly Neighborhood Quantum Hobo Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Outside the M-brane look'n in Posts: 5,403	Deadline Wednesday at around 9:00PM EST.

10-26-2006, 09:28 AM	#465
Moogle0119 The REAL Lord of the Dance Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Narshe Caves Posts: 397	Tick Tock The deadline's up

10-27-2006, 10:59 AM	#466
Sithdarth Friendly Neighborhood Quantum Hobo Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Outside the M-brane look'n in Posts: 5,403	Once again the SGC gathers to put to death one they deem a traitor. Zats at the ready they surrond Mr. Bookworm and fire in rapid succession. As their victims body vanishes into nothing they notice something strange. Replicators are immune to Zats and so Mr. Bookworm Vanillia Tauri was gone. As the few remaining members awaken they find Moogle0119 quite torn up and looking rather haggard. Slowly he begins to mouth words so softly no one can quite here them. Suddenly he falls into a heap a dark mist drifting out of him the detached limb of a replicator still sticking out of his back. As the SGC looks on in hour the dark mist raises up as if to menace them before slowly dissapating. Thus ended Moogle0119 Vanilla Townie(Newly possesed).

10-27-2006, 11:08 AM	#467
Moogle0119 The REAL Lord of the Dance Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Narshe Caves Posts: 397	Wow I didn't even know that had happened to me, in any case good luck town I hope you get that replicator!

10-27-2006, 03:38 PM	#468
Mr.Bookworm YYYEEEEEAAAAAAHHH Join Date: Jul 2006 Posts: 2,034	Good luck. And start postin' people!