My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[Solid Snake]

Oh, and there's also this.

As a general rule, modkills are designed to be as disadvantageous to the player and their faction as possible. A modkill on Town will end the Day (thus preventing them from lynching), and a modkill on any kind of scum will keep the Day going (so that the Town can ideally lynch another scum).

From: This website.

Like actually I think this Modkill ending D1 was more advantageous to Town than the alternative option (Modkill + D1 lynch) would have been, but that's my opinion. Those are the actual rules.

[Sifright]

Fair enough I recant my previous testimony. I clearly need to rules lawyer better :P

Edit: I've actually not read through the rules list very throughly i'm going to go correct that oversight now.

[Nikose Tyris]

To be fair this is the first time you've even mildly refuted the SK role I've cast you in.

SOMETHING TO HIDE, SNAKE?! [DUN DUN DUUUUUN]

[Revising Ocelot]

Lynching the self-proclaimed Doctor when nobody else has stepped forth to claim "that's bullshit, I'm the Doctor" is town-suicidal. It's also unlikely that one of our two non-posters is the Doctor as that'd let the fake Doctor run free, and they've been active.

Either the scum don't believe Sifright is the Doctor, or they believe him and are delaying a night kill to avoid verifying his claim and deter suspicion.

I've already got HoS on Nikose, but this reinforces it.

[Revising Ocelot]

Oh, and because of all that I believe Sifright is telling the truth.

[Sifright]

RO I am "Doctor whooves" but I'm not actually a town doctor like my character name is "Doctor whooves The doctor" Which from what i'm wikied is supposed to be a reference to doctor who but i'm not actually the town doctor like i have no power role ability.

the only thing i started with was knowing that Karesh is fluttershy

[Revising Ocelot]

Oh, and both Sif and Snake have edited posts. I thought that wasn't allowed, same as deleting posts?

[Solid Snake]

Originally Posted by Nikose Tyris

To be fair this is the first time you've even mildly refuted the SK role I've cast you in.

SOMETHING TO HIDE, SNAKE?! [DUN DUN DUUUUUN]

Pssshhh.

Hey Nik think logically for a second.
(I know this is difficult for you.)
If I'm SK and I win if everyone is dead.
Do I advocate the option in which only one person dies D1?
Or do I deeply prefer Sifright's logic and a D1 in which the SK actually "gains the most" by offing two schlubs?

(Also the fact that the SK would have benefited tremendously from the abnormal possibility of two D1 deaths is another, albeit minor, reason to be against Sifright's preferred solution.)

In the end, though, I'm more interested in hunting Mafiates right now than the SK, Mafiates are the greater threat, particularly now that the Cult is apparently gone. Also, before N1's writeup the existence of an SK wasn't even confirmed, and why waste time debating hypotheticals D1 when I can hunt Cult and Mafiate roles I know exist?

[Bard The 5th LW]

Big football game, dont have time to go through the backlog

[Solid Snake]

Ocelot: Fenris' rules are less strict than mine. I'm not sure if I'm personally a fan of being able to edit, but if others are editing I have to take similar liberties to keep on par.
Also, Sifright has claimed "the Doctor" (as in Doctor Whooves, a character) but not "the Doctor" (as in the role that heals people), unless I'm mistaken. He's said he's Vanilla.