Urban Mafia

[Death by Stabbing]

HoS: Tendroni

Clearly you are trying to turn all of us against each other by lashing out at random people for no reason. If the town is going to win this then we can't be irrational. We have to sniff out the mafia using logic and reasoning.

[Tendronai]

Originally Posted by Death by Stabbing

HoS: Tendroni

Clearly you are trying to turn all of us against each other by lashing out at random people for no reason. If the town is going to win this then we can't be irrational. We have to sniff out the mafia using logic and reasoning.

You do remember I'm the GM confirmed Mason leading roleblocker, right? You're not exactly helping me think of you as town, here.

In fact, I'm going to block you tonight after we lynch LHN. If a kill isn't stopped, I'll owe you an apology. I doubt I'm going to have to, though.

[Death by Stabbing]

Originally Posted by Tendronai

You do remember I'm the GM confirmed Mason leading roleblocker, right? You're not exactly helping me think of you as town, here.

In fact, I'm going to block you tonight after we lynch LHN. If a kill isn't stopped, I'll owe you an apology. I doubt I'm going to have to, though.

Oh so now you're blocking people and threatening people just because they disagree with you? Fantastic detective work. We're all safe now. You'll probably get to the real mafiates eventually.

[Pink Bunny]

I think DBS is being a bit stupid with the hints that Tendronai isn't helping town. On the other hand, I do agree with him on the aspect that his list is flawed and has biases with it. I mean as it stands the guy tried to set Demetrius and me up until he was one vote away from death. That is hardly a trustworthy individual to place all your faith into.

And I still don't buy that theres no strings attached. Mafia got shafted way too hard for that list to be accurate. If there's no errors in that list, then the game is more than likely broken.

[Death by Stabbing]

Originally Posted by Pink Bunny

I think DBS is being a bit stupid with the hints that Tendronai isn't helping town.

Yeah just a bit...

And I still don't buy that theres no strings attached. Mafia got shafted way too hard for that list to be accurate. If there's no errors in that list, then the game is more than likely broken.

Yeah that's a good point there...the mafia probably should have been decimated...no wonder this game has taken 2 months to play XD

[Ole' Dude With the Face]

Originally Posted by DBS

Yeah but what if LHN/Rhiya is a PO or something?

We just lost two POs last night. I'd be willing to guess that we don't have any POs left at this point.

Originally Posted by Pink Bunny

And I still don't buy that theres no strings attached. Mafia got shafted way too hard for that list to be accurate. If there's no errors in that list, then the game is more than likely broken.

I agree, but the fact that b_real insisted so heavily on either BHS or LHN/Rhiya being lynched to show that the information he was slowly giving out was good seemed like he was confident that it would show mafia. And he would know, as we've been shown that he was indeed a mafia traitor of both the Gang and Mafia.

When he continued to give out the rest (Rygar and SSB) it seemed that he was more being forced into doing it and would rather not have. Due to this, I find it more likely that the remaining person on the list still alive, SSB is most likely a fake thrown out to the town so he could still be useful later on.

Originally Posted by DBS

...the mafia probably should have been decimated...

Both the Mafia and the Gang has been decimated due to b_real. He gave up both Dons, and helped to further implicate two more people. Include himself and thats basically 6 mafiates/gangsters (b_real counts twice once for each) that due to him have been revealed. Add in the other two scum we have found and thats a total of 8 scum gone down. I would say that counts pretty high in the "decimation" category.

[Captain Combustible]

Originally Posted by Ole' Dude With the Face

Both the Mafia and the Gang has been decimated due to b_real. He gave up both Dons, and helped to further implicate two more people. Include himself and thats basically 6 mafiates/gangsters (b_real counts twice once for each) that due to him have been revealed. Add in the other two scum we have found and thats a total of 8 scum gone down. I would say that counts pretty high in the "decimation" category.

I know we found BHS but what other scum have we found?

I also agree that we should lynch Rhiya/LHN because B_real gave Rhiya/LHN up when he thought he still had a chance of winning.
Vote: Rhiya

[Ole' Dude With the Face]

I am referring to Masked Jedi the Mafia Lover, and Doppler12 the Gang Doctor. I don't remember when they were killed/lynched or how they went out, since it was during the time I was inactive and most everything I read to catch up has blurred together.

[Professor Smarmiarty]

Originally Posted by Captain Combustible

here is your original roleclaim, note that you mention nothing of being un-lynchable.

To be honest I wasn't told that I was unlynchable. I don't know why that happened.

Are we just voting LHN based on Be_Real's list? Because we've already seen on person, Rygar I think, who was on it and was town. Thus I don't think we should blindly follow it unless there is some other evidence I missed in all the cries of "die scum die."

[Tendronai]

Originally Posted by Ole' Dude With the Face

I am referring to Masked Jedi the Mafia Lover, and Doppler12 the Gang Doctor. I don't remember when they were killed/lynched or how they went out, since it was during the time I was inactive and most everything I read to catch up has blurred together.

Masked Jedi was night-killed by Nayno, I believe, and Doppler was lynched.

So... any luck in getting any of the inactives (Sheb, Doc Ock Rokc, and Hikari) replaced?