My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[rpgdemon]

Hey, Ryander, what have you been up to? You haven't really accused anyone except for going for whoever other people are going for.

You've got to have reasons/your own thoughts on this stuff, right?

Honestly, I'd like to implore anyone who has voted for anyone with very little said about it to go into detail and elaborate, with whatever reasons you have. If you don't have good reason for it, it might be telling, and if you have a good reason for it, we really need as much information as we can get now, if the Mafia do have five people.

Related: I think the five people in the mafia number came off of Nikose originally, for what it's worth?

[Ryanderman]

I'm voting for you, because you've been acting scummy. I think the logic for why Sifright and Karesh are town, regardless of how inconsistent or suspcious Sifright has been acting, is pretty clear. And so the fact that you ignored that logic and pushed - through several walls of text - for a Sifright lynch is incredibly suspicious.

And then, when people started turning on you and voting for you, and you posted this:

Originally Posted by rpgdemon

Blargh, is search broken for anyone else? In any case, yeah, we probably should explore other options, as well, since I think I've said just about everything I have to suspect against Sifright.

Do you guys remember who it was who said that scum last game are less likely to be so this game? Since I still highly suspect that person, since I remember they were scum last game.

Also, Bard is pretty much doing the same thing he did last game, which was not doing anything except then jumping on whoever seems to be a good person to jump. I'm saying this only because I don't remember him posting much, except to vote someone, and then vanish. I can't search, so I can't verify that this is actually true and not just faulty memory. If someone who can search can check those two for me, that'd be boss.

My scum radar, such as it is, went crazy. Since your attack on Sifright failed, you backed off and tried to turn suspicion on someone else. Anyone else. And you're still doing so now.

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by Ryanderman

I'm voting for you, because you've been acting scummy. I think the logic for why Sifright and Karesh are town, regardless of how inconsistent or suspcious Sifright has been acting, is pretty clear. And so the fact that you ignored that logic and pushed - through several walls of text - for a Sifright lynch is incredibly suspicious.

And then, when people started turning on you and voting for you, and you posted this:



My scum radar, such as it is, went crazy. Since your attack on Sifright failed, you backed off and tried to turn suspicion on someone else. Anyone else. And you're still doing so now.

I agree with you some what Ryanderman but that doesn't change the fact that there are a host of players who aren't communicating.

[Ryanderman]

Originally Posted by Sifright

I agree with you some what Ryanderman but that doesn't change the fact that there are a host of players who aren't communicating.

Agreed. But that doesn't lessen my suspicion of rpg, who could easily be trying to leverage that legitimate concern to distract from him.

[Bard The 5th LW]

The way I see it, Sif and RPG BOTH make sense, and only one of them can be scum. Sif is flopping all about, but if he was lying then wouldn't the real Fluttershy come forward in regards to his and Karesh's bluff? That is really his saving grace, the lack of other fluttershys. Otherwise I'd just lynch him on his fickleness, because it makes him serem unsure of where he is going.

On the other hand, there might not be a Fluttershy. Last game, we had a safelist, and a a few main characters were on it. If we are to assume can happen, then Fluttershy or any of the mane cast can be on that safe list.

Basically, this will prove quite a bit. If we lynch RPG, and he's scum, then there is no more reason to doubt Sif and Karesh. If we lynch Sif, and he's scum, then we lynch Karesh next day. Both of them seem like equally likely targets, and one is a twofer, but I'll pitch my vote.

VOTE: RPG

Sif's been floppy on his case, but Karesh has backed it up. If their wrong, then they both get hit. I doubt Mafia would put that much focus on two off their own team members. Their numbers are (probably) small as it is. So unless the real fluttershy would please stand up, then this is where my vote lies.

[Sifright]

Originally Posted by Bard The 5th LW

The way I see it, Sif and RPG BOTH make sense, and only one of them can be scum. Sif is flopping all about, but if he was lying then wouldn't the real Fluttershy come forward in regards to his and Karesh's bluff? That is really his saving grace, the lack of other fluttershys. Otherwise I'd just lynch him on his fickleness, because it makes him serem unsure of where he is going.

On the other hand, there might not be a Fluttershy. Last game, we had a safelist, and a a few main characters were on it. If we are to assume can happen, then Fluttershy or any of the mane cast can be on that safe list.

Basically, this will prove quite a bit. If we lynch RPG, and he's scum, then there is no more reason to doubt Sif and Karesh. If we lynch Sif, and he's scum, then we lynch Karesh next day. Both of them seem like equally likely targets, and one is a twofer, but I'll pitch my vote.

VOTE: RPG

Sif's been floppy on his case, but Karesh has backed it up. If their wrong, then they both get hit. I doubt Mafia would put that much focus on two off their own team members. Their numbers are (probably) small as it is. So unless the real fluttershy would please stand up, then this is where my vote lies.

False logic both of us could be townies. given your lack of activity coupled with jumping on a bandwagon to lynch RPG i'm worried as fuck about you now.

[Sifright]

especially given your insistence that one or the other HAS to be a scum because that patently isn't true.

[Bard The 5th LW]

I didn't say one HAS to be scum, just said both of them couldn't be.

[Ryanderman]

Though actually, Sifright, Karesh, and rpgdemon could all be scum and going at each other for our benefit. But I doubt it.

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Originally Posted by Ryanderman

Though actually, Sifright, Karesh, and rpgdemon could all be scum and going at each other for our benefit. But I doubt it.

Yeah. I doubt that too.
From an outside perspective all three of us would just be drawing far more attention than is intelligent at this stage. Had one of us gained a concrete position as a leader amongst the town then maybe they'd lead a charge against a mafioso on some premise to secure their own validity. But that's not really a smart play at this point anyway. What they'd want is as many town dead as quickly as possible so that the game can end before the Vig/SKs odds of hitting them become too great.