My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia

[Professor Smarmiarty]

Ninjaed by snake- I came to that conclusion becuase I'm sensible and not in whatever backwards logic land you live in?

[IHateMakingNames]

Originally Posted by Smarty McBarrelpants

Vote: IHMN

Originally Posted by Bard The 5th LW

HOS: Hawk, Snake, and IHMN
...
Vote: IHMN

[Fenris]

I think this is right Vote count:

Smarty McB 1
Nikose

Snake
Karesh
Ramary
Aldurin

Ramary
Gregness

rpgdemon
Hawk

Nikose
IHMN
Sifright

IHMN
Snake
SMcB
Bard

Bookworm
Geminex

12 to lynch, deadline Thursday afternoon.

[Professor Smarmiarty]

IHMN, are you going to keep just posting pictures and gifs? Because if so I'mgoing to pull to lynch you no matter what if simply to stop the ridiculous ponification.

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Wow this freaking spiraled out of my ability to keep up to date lickity split.
I see the logic behind Snake's actions but it seems to be a bit too callous of a trap. If IHMN is voted off we'll never see him respond to a quote with just a .gif again.
It won't be the same, even if someone steps up to the plate and starts imitating. There can be only one and for this game it seems to be IHMN.

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Also what episode was this one from?

[rpgdemon]

Originally Posted by Solid Snake

If IHMN flips Town, I'll feel it's more likely that Sifright's scum, and vice-versa, unless Nik flips Scum.

Faulty logic. That's the gambler's fallacy. If, let's say, they both have a 50% chance of being scum, the fact that one isn't scum doesn't mean that the other is, nor does it increase the odds that the other is.


I propose that, until Day 1 is over, we don't listen to Snake. Just ignore him. After that, he can do whatever he wants, we can do whatever we want, but if he wants a Day 1 lynch to himself, or someone else, we shouldn't give it to him. (I'm assuming Jester's win means the town loses? Or is it just a separate win?)

Right now, all he's doing is keeping people from voting properly, and keeping things incredibly disorganized, making it impossible to pin anyone down as scum. Really, from all his ravings, voting has gone haywire, and the scum now have a huge haven to hide with, because of all the double mobius reacharounds and Xanatos Gambits flying everywhere.

If he is really trying to be helpful, then he's suffering from a severe case of fancy play syndrome. It's what happens, for example, in Magic (For those that play the game), when you attack your weak guy into a more powerful blocker, with mana available and cards in hand. Against an opponent who plays well, they might be bluffed into not blocking, as they don't want to risk some sort of trick. Against a new player, they'll block every time, since they don't even consider the combat trick, and they'll laugh at you for playing stupidly.

If he's trying to be helpful, Snake is the guy that attempted a bluff, that the new player was too inexperienced to read. Meaning, whatever he's doing, he's being fancy and neat with it, and it's going way over the heads of the town and actually actively hurting it. The scum now has a huge hive to hide in, and Snake will say anyone who votes AT ALL is scum, since "Nope, I accused them! Hah! I can't believe it! You fell for the trap again! Man! Again! Look, I caught every scum with the same trap four times!"

[rpgdemon]

PS: Would someone please tell me what being Serial Killer would mean? It's a lead that we have, and if I'm an unknown/passive scummy role, just take me out for the day, so that Snake definitely won't get his Jestery kill, if that's his angle.

Until further notice, I'mma go ahead and
vote: RPGDemon

Town victory still counts when you're dead?

[Karrrrrrrrrrrresche]

Originally Posted by rpgdemon

Faulty logic. That's the gambler's fallacy. If, let's say, they both have a 50% chance of being scum, the fact that one isn't scum doesn't mean that the other is, nor does it increase the odds that the other is.


I propose that, until Day 1 is over, we don't listen to Snake. Just ignore him. After that, he can do whatever he wants, we can do whatever we want, but if he wants a Day 1 lynch to himself, or someone else, we shouldn't give it to him. (I'm assuming Jester's win means the town loses? Or is it just a separate win?)

Right now, all he's doing is keeping people from voting properly, and keeping things incredibly disorganized, making it impossible to pin anyone down as scum. Really, from all his ravings, voting has gone haywire, and the scum now have a huge haven to hide with, because of all the double mobius reacharounds and Xanatos Gambits flying everywhere.

If he is really trying to be helpful, then he's suffering from a severe case of fancy play syndrome. It's what happens, for example, in Magic (For those that play the game), when you attack your weak guy into a more powerful blocker, with mana available and cards in hand. Against an opponent who plays well, they might be bluffed into not blocking, as they don't want to risk some sort of trick. Against a new player, they'll block every time, since they don't even consider the combat trick, and they'll laugh at you for playing stupidly.

If he's trying to be helpful, Snake is the guy that attempted a bluff, that the new player was too inexperienced to read. Meaning, whatever he's doing, he's being fancy and neat with it, and it's going way over the heads of the town and actually actively hurting it. The scum now has a huge hive to hide in, and Snake will say anyone who votes AT ALL is scum, since "Nope, I accused them! Hah! I can't believe it! You fell for the trap again! Man! Again! Look, I caught every scum with the same trap four times!"

Unvote: Snake

FTHOO: rpgdemon

Fuck MTG.
Friendship is magic.

[Solid Snake]

Originally Posted by rpgdemon

Until further notice, I'mma go ahead and
vote: RPGDemon

...
...You were doing so relatively decently with your logic in criticizing me, like seriously yours was the first criticism of me that actually made me do a double take and say "...Huh..."

...and then you did this.